Thursday, February 10, 2011

The Physics Of A Falling Coffee Cup



On Tuesday this incredible thing happened at work. I didn't think such a thing was possible. The laws of falling bodies would explain it, I'm sure. If I knew more about physics, I could say how and why it happened.

What happened was this: I was talking to my co-worker, and standing behind the public service desk in the library, holding my cup of tea. I was getting ready to make an important point--so perhaps I was starting to wave my hand, I don't know ---but all of a sudden the mug slipped from my fingers, and dropped to the carpeted floor. As I lost hold, I thought, "Oh, this is going to be an absolute disaster. The tea will pour out all over the carpet, and the cup might even break. It will be noisy and there will be a big, embarrassing mess." In a fraction of a second, I thought all of this.

As the cup went down I felt the tea splash onto my black work pants. I stepped back from the point of impact, and looked down, expecting to see spilled tea and possibly cup shards everywhere.

Instead I saw that my coffee cup had made a perfect landing, right-side-up on the carpet, as if it had been carefully placed there. A perfect landing! I was stunned. Other than the tea that had splashed my legs, there was not a drop of tea to be seen anywhere. I couldn't believe it.

I looked around the room. Students had their heads bowed over textbooks; they sat talking to each other. No one had noticed my near-calamity. My cup sat there on the floor quietly, still mostly full. Julie said, "You can still drink it."

I reached down and picked it up. I was so tickled. I couldn't get over the fact that we could just go on with our conversation as if nothing had happened.

It was like being on an episode of Bewitched, and having Samantha twitch everything back into the cup and set it upright. I felt like one of the clueless mortals on the show, who are always rubbing their eyes and swearing off drink, because they see things that defy the laws of physics.

I was so puzzled by how it happened, I visited some physics websites, to see if I could find answers. The cup doesn't have a flexible spine, so it can't re-orient itself like a cat. It is the conservation of angular momentum, by the way, that allows the cat to rotate its body and slow its rate of rotation enough so that it lands on its feet safely. Also, the cat manipulates its moment of inertia, by extending and retracting its legs and rotating its tail, so it can change the speed at which it rotates, which gives it control over which part of its body hits the ground.

But I digress. Obviously, my coffee cup didn't need to re-orient itself anyway, since it slipped out of my hands bottom-first. So the whole issue of the cat is moot. Now here's an interesting question: Do you know which would hit the floor first if dropped together? My cup of tea or a feather?

Well, it depends. If a certified Joy Thief suddenly walked in and sucked all the air out of the room, so that you had a vacuum, you could drop my cup of tea and a feather at the same time, and they would both land together. Why? Because when there is no air resistance, the only force working on the cup and the feather is gravity, and when gravity is the only force, objects accelerate at the same rate.

On Earth, this acceleration value is 9.8 m/s/s. This is such an important value in physics that it is given a special name - the acceleration of gravity - and a special symbol - g.

Now, on the other hand, if a blowhard followed on the heels of the Joy Thief and suddenly filled the room with hot air, so that you no longer had a vacuum, the cup of tea and the feather would fall at different rates. Because now air resistance would be another factor affecting the fall of the objects. The cup would drop faster, because it has more mass, and it takes longer for it to reach a point where there is enough air resistance to balance the downward force of gravity and keep it from accelerating any further. This point, once it is reached, is known as terminal velocity. The feather, having less mass, doesn't have to fall long before it encounters enough air resistance to bring it to terminal velocity --at which point it ceases acceleration.

My thanks to the website "Physics Classroom" for explaining all this to me. It has finally made clear that whole feather vs. stone question, which I never understood before. But of course it doesn't have anything to do with my original question. How did my coffee cup land so straight and true? Shouldn't the impact have made it tip over? My crash course in physics has taught me that you can calculate the impact force of an object by measuring its stopping distance --how far it continues to travel after the impact. But my coffee cup didn't appear to travel at all. Does that mean that the impact force was "0"?


Or maybe the cup bounced straight up, and came down again, and all the liquid poured back in, like in a cartoon. Yeah, that must have been it.

If I go back to my cubicle and drop a cup full of tea, will I get the same result?

13 comments:

  1. I dont know anything about physics either, (I dont even know if I spelled it right!)but the stars must have been aligned juuuust right for you and your tea. What a wonderful moment in time! Haha, maybe you do have some hidden powers...

    ReplyDelete
  2. you had me until the "cat." i call it serendipity.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you so much for the crash course in basic Newtonian physics. It has clarified an, as yet unanswered mystery,which has plagued me for years.
    As I was carrying my new Bonaire BCM-6100 humidifier down to the basement, just one step from the top, I was hit by an apparent gravity storm. Exactly what happened after that is in dispute, but I’m quite sure that I never reached terminal velocity as I recall some pretty aggressive acceleration (g) right up to the point of impact. (And, similar your cup, I didn’t experience a significant bounce, if any) Now, based on your short lesson in basic physics, but for the difference in air resistance, I should have finished second since the BCM-6100 had a slight head start. The fact that I beat the humidifier to the bottom (not by a lot, mind you) must confirm another fact of physics: that I have less air resistance than a major home appliance.

    H.B.

    ReplyDelete
  4. ...oh, and as for your cup of tea. I'm guessing it probably had a cat hair in it.

    H.B.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Sip-a-tube is not have this problem. I calculate very low probabilistic curve of this event. Simone Unit, do not try this again! The human beings should get the sip-a-tube and not have this problems.

    ReplyDelete
  6. H.B., those gravity storms sure are a bear. I take it you didn't land right side up. Ouch. I'm glad you recovered and all your marbles seem to be more or less in place. I have to admit, it does make a good story. I imagine you do have more mass than a BCM-6100. Now what I'd like to know is, whereabouts did the BCM-6100 land? Hopefully not on your head.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Outer Space Alien,

    I'm almost afraid to ask what a Sip-a-tube is, and where it attaches on your body.

    ReplyDelete
  8. If I were there, I would definitely have sworn off Boulevard Wheat with my Country Sweet.

    ReplyDelete
  9. i think we have all missed the most important point, which is: what the hell was in that tea, that caused you to expound so? i think that is the qeustion of the hour.

    ReplyDelete
  10. i see that i have misspelled the word "question." yes, i see it. i am aware. such is my lot these days.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Well, of course your fingers can't be expected to keep up with that fast little mind of yours.

    ReplyDelete
  12. sure wish you had that on video!!!! would go viral.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Not have fear, Simone Unit! We are all have the sip-a-tube in our birth pods!

    ReplyDelete